ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY FROM ARISTOTLE TO ST. AUGUSTINE
PHH 3140
Spring Semester 1998
Syllabus


Blake Hestir
Office: 286 Dodd Hall
Phone: 644 0823
email: bhestir@mailer.fsu.edu
Office hours: MWF 11:00-12:00; or by appointment

1. Course Description

This course is designed to offer students a thorough overview of ancient philosophy from Aristotle through St. Augustine. Aristotle entered Plato's Academy at the age of 17, and he remained there for almost 20 years before leaving Athens after Plato's death in 348/7 B.C. He later returned to Athens to found his own school, the Lyceum. Although Aristotle and Plato agree in principle on a number of philosophical issues, Aristotle challenges his teacher in many important ways and offers alternative metaphysical, ethical, and political theories which rank among the greatest in the Western philosophical tradition. We shall examine the development of Aristotle's metaphysics from its appearance in the Categories through its maturation in the Metaphysics; along the way we shall take a look at Aristotle's logic, "psychology," and physical theory. Finally, in light of the recent revival of interest in virtue ethics, we shall consider some of the more intriguing theoretical issues that arise in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics. There are three major schools of thought which develop out of or are in response to Plato and Aristotle: Epicureanism, Stoicism, and Skepticism. Each of these schools is an interesting study in how a philosophical position can shape a particular way of life. We shall spend time reviewing the more important contributions each of these schools has made with respect to its place in the history of ideas. Finally, we shall turn to a general overview of two flavors of Neoplatonism, a somewhat curious and radical recasting of Plato's philosophy which forms the bridge between ancient and medieval thought.

2. Course Requirements
2.1. Examinations

The two mid-terms and final examination will be multiple choice, identification, true/false, etc.: they are tests of your absorption of information and do not call for any particular philosophical acumen. You are responsible for material introduced in class and material in the texts and handouts that is discussed in class.

The second mid-term and final examinations are NOT cumulative.

2.2. Papers

The three papers are to be short: each 4-5 pp. typewritten, or the equivalent of 1,000-1,500 words.

Topics will be distributed to the class no later than a week prior to the assigned due date.

The papers are to be original work, involving philosophical criticism of ancient Greek theories and arguments on philosophical questions. You are not required to use any material beyond the assigned reading, and I prefer that you don't: these are not to be "research" papers so much as papers that express your own reflection on the philosophers and philosophical issues. If you do decide to use any outside material, whether it is assigned reading or additional material, you must provide full references.

Plagiarism and cheating: I strictly adhere to the FSU Academic Honor Code published in the Florida State University Bulletin and Student Handbook.

Gordon Rule requirement: You are required by FSU's interpretation of the so- called "Gordon Rule" to write a total of 3,000 words for this course. The combination of the three papers should satisfy this requirement.

2.3. Grade

Your grade will be determined by your grades on the examinations (each counting 1/6) and the papers (each counting 1/6). In borderline cases, class performance will be taken into account.

2.4. Students with Disabilities

Students with disabilities needing academic accommodations should: 1. Register with and provide documentation to the Student Disability resource Center (SDRC); 2. Bring a letter to me from the SDRC indicating you need academic accommodations. This should be done within the first week of class.

3. Schedule of Readings, Lectures, Exams, and Papers

NOTE: Changes to this schedule may be necessary; if so, I will announce them in class.

Jan. 7, 9: Introduction; Aristotle and Plato: Contrasting Metaphysics; Aristotle's Early Metaphysics.
Readings: selections from Metaphysics I (pp. 221-240), Categories 1-5, 12-13 (pp. 1-12), Topics I 9 (pp. 75-76), and On Ideas (pp. 558- 563).
Jan. 12, 14, 16: Metaphysics cont.; Aristotle's Methodology.
Readings: selections from Prior Analytics (pp. 29-36), and Posterior Analytics (pp. 37-68).
Jan. 19: Martin Luther King, Jr. Day. No Class.
Jan. 21, 23: Aristotle on Nature and Change.
Readings: selections from Physics I-III (pp. 83-126).
Jan. 26, 28, 30: Nature and Change cont.; Aristotle's "Psychology" (Theory of the Soul)
Readings: selections from De Anima (pp. 169-205).
Mid-term Examination I: Monday, February 2.
Feb. 4, 6: Aristotle's Later Metaphysics
Readings: selections from Metaphysics IV, V, VII-IX, XII, XIII (pp. 244-346); selections from Physics VIII 1, 4-6 (pp. 137-144).
Paper I due: beginning of class, Monday, February 9.
Feb. 9, 11, 13: Later Metaphysics cont.
Feb. 16, 18, 20: Aristotle's Ethics: Goodness, Happiness, and Contemplation.
Readings: selections from Nicomachean Ethics I-II (pp. 347-376), V-VII (pp. 391-417), X (pp. 433-449).
Feb. 23, 25, 27: Aristotle's Ethics cont.
March 2, 4 Early Skepticism
Readings: Pyrrhonism handout; Inwood and Gerson, pp. 173-183.
Mid-term examination II: Friday, March 6.
March 9-13: Spring Break
March 16, 18, 20: Epicureanism,
Readings: Inwood and Gerson, pp. 4-69.
Paper II due: beginning of class, Friday, March 20.
Mar. 23, 25, 27: Stoicism
Readings: Inwood and Gerson, pp. 78-156.
Mar. 30, Apr. 1, 3: Later Skepticism
Readings: Inwood and Gerson, pp. 159-239.
Apr. 6, 8, 10: Skepticism cont.
Apr. 13, 15, 17: Neoplatonism: Plotinus
Readings: O'Brien
Apr. 20, 22, 24: Christian Neoplatonism: Augustine
Readings: King
Paper III due: beginning of class, Friday, April 24.
Final examination: Thursday, April 30, 10:00AM-12:00

4. Texts
4.1. Required Texts

Inwood, Brad, and L.P. Gerson, eds., Hellenistic Philosophy: Introductory Readings. Indianapolis, Indiana & Cambridge, England: Hackett Publishing Co., Inc., 1988.

Irwin, Terence and Gail Fine, Aristotle: Selections. Indianapolis, Indiana and Cambridge, England: Hackett Publishing Co., Inc., 1995.

King, Peter, Augustine: Against the Academicians and the Teacher. Indianapolis, Indiana and Cambridge, England: Hackett Publishing Co., Inc., 1995.

O'Brien, Elmer, ed., The Essential Plotinus. Indianapolis, Indiana: Hackett Publishing Co., Inc., 1981.

4.2. Secondary Material on Reserve

I have placed the following texts and articles on reserve in the Strozier library. Others may follow in time. You may check these out with your FSU card for two hours at a time. Some of them are short and can easily be photocopied. These are not required reading, although I think you will find the Ackrill book in particular to be a helpful summary of Aristotle.

Ackrill, J.L., Aristotle the Philosopher. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981.
Barnes, Jonathan, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
Ross, W.D., Aristotle. London: Methuen & Co., 1923.